While reading Danielle’s post, “Edna’s
Awakening,” I found it interesting that she made the argument that Edna’s death
could be related to the pressure that society placed on mothers during this
time. Not only do I believe that society put “pressure” on mothers at this time
period, but I also believe that this is still prevalent in society today
(Reynolds). I know that on practically an everyday basis while I am scrolling
through Facebook or watching a TV station, such as MTV or E! News, I constantly
hear about female celebrities, such as Kim Kardashian and Beyonce, being bashed
if they do not have their children with them at all times. I also see numerous
Facebook statuses of people judging moms if they go out for a night with
friends. Society has a huge toll on people’s lives every single day, and it is
sad that people care about what others are doing that much. In this case, I
agree with Danielle that Edna’s suicide was related to the fact that she was
not necessarily happy with being a mother, or as we said in class, that she did
not think she was a trophy mother. For example, when we are told that Edna’s
children spent the summer away with her grandmother, it is described that the
trip was a “sort of relief” for her (18). She needed a break, and she was okay
with being away from her children because they were in good hands.
Because I
have seen my older sister, who has three children, need a break occasionally, I
understand how Edna is feeling. Being away from your child, in my eyes, does
not make you a bad parent. It just means that you need time for yourself. So my
question is, what are your thoughts on this? Do you think she is a bad mother
because she is okay with her children’s absence?
I'm okay with it because, while I am not a parent, I am a person and I know how important it is to take time for yourself in order to preserve your sanity. I think Edna is a very "hands-off" parent in that she wants her children to learn for herself and she will not help if she is there for them twenty-four seven. It is similar to the argument that both you and Danielle made bout how a mother should not be judged for being away from her children. It could be that the freedom they get from their children is what makes them a better parent and will hopefully help them not to resent their children later in life.
ReplyDeleteI don't think that Edna is necessarily a bad mother but I don't think she should have become a mother. It clearly does not make her happy much of the time.
ReplyDelete